Almost every piece of advice about selling, including a lot on this site, contains in one way or another, the notion that in order to be successful, you have to solve a problem for the buyer.
In other words, scratch the itch and the itch will go away.
We all know that is not always true, the itch often remains, just a bit relieved, or satisfied for the moment, perhaps to return.
There is a further step you can take.
Frame the proposal as an investment, something that will deliver ongoing value, rather than just be the antidote to an itch, the solution to a problem.
Many years ago I worked for Cerebos in Australia. One of the now disappeared brands we had was Cerola muesli, back in the days when muesli was a bit unusual. The breakfast cereal market was nowhere near as fragmented and competitive as it is today. Cerola was doing OK, generating increasing sales at good margins, albeit a minnow in comparison to the major cereals on the market.
With the support of the then marketing manager, I worked up a proposal to spend a significant chunk of money to manufacture and market a ‘muesli bar,’ a snack product that would sit between the perceived goodness of breakfast cereals, and convenience and taste of a confectionary bar. A wholesome breakfast on the run, and snack. I had a lot of subjective material, trends that seemed to be converging, gaps in consumer behaviour that may accommodate such a product, an admittedly dodgy bit of limited market research done with prototypes made by hand in the lab, and a strong conviction.
My failure to convince the MD at the time was total, and quick. No way would he accept such a proposal in the absence of strong quantitative reasons, little risk, and certainty of a quick return.
Nine months after getting my arse kicked for proposing something so dumb, Uncle Toby’s came out with their version of a muesli bar, and cleaned up.
The lesson I took away from that disappointment was that framing a proposal to spend money to a profit sensitive MD is like suggesting we stick a few holes in the bottom of the boat, and hope they do not let in any water. Instead, the proposal should have been framed as an opportunity to turbo charge the motor we already had, an investment in a profitable future. Such a framing would have had a way better chance of gaining the support of the MD.
A second lesson I took, which was the outcome of youthful arrogance and stupidity, is that you never say ‘I told you so’ to someone who does not like to be told.
