Strategy development is driven by the need to make difficult choices with less than complete information. The successful see a problem to solve before anyone else realises there is a problem, and reap the rewards.
When you think you have all the information you need to make a risk-less choice, my advice would be to look again. Either the path you are contemplating is tactical rather than strategic, or you are simply following some orthodoxy that will not lead you anywhere new or different.
The great and unusual skill is in nurturing the capability to generate an insight that makes a difference. It is challenging to see a situation as presenting a problem to be solved that others did not see, until you have solved it. Then they rush to follow, often commoditising your insight in the process. The classic case here is iTunes, a solution to a problem nobody saw until Apple made it obvious there was a goldmine hiding behind the fence. Apple built a first mover advantage, and by not stopping the innovation process, ensured competitors followed without catching up. Competition just added to the breadth and depth of the market Apple continues to dominate.
Every major behaviour changing innovation I can think of has solved a problem that either nobody else saw or had failed to solve. In the latter case, Thomas Edison and the light bulb are the classic case. Many people had been working on solving the problem of the filaments burning out with a flash when a charge was applied, but it was Edison who came out with the solution first, and is therefore remembered as the ‘inventor’ of the light bulb.
Anybody for a faster horse?
